Enter and Exit: Intervention
Investigating the position and role of quantifiers in German multiple wh questions, among other structures, Beck (1996a) proposes the informal ban in (1), illustrating abstractly her definitions reproduced in (2) and (3).
(1)

(2)

(3)

The paradigmatic instance of a ROLF violation of interest here (ignoring other phenomena discussed by Beck) is arguably a structure like (6), in which the negative quantifier niemand ‘nobody’ sits in between two wh question words, apparently inducing the ungrammaticality by the combi nation of (1)–(3).
(4)

The relevant contrasting fact from German is that the variant of (4) in which the negative quantifier follows both wh-expressions is well formed.
(5)

Intervention qua MQSC apparently accounts for the contrast. Note, however, that ‘‘[t]he distinction between S-Structural and LF movement is absolutely crucial’’ (Beck 1996a, 18) for such an explanation, within the limits of Beck’s syntax (see note 7 below). In other words, LF must involve phrasal movement of all wh-material into a position like Spec,CP in order for ROLF to apply. (As a matter of fact, Beck goes to some lengths to account for additional LF movements of items that it is not at all clear should move, including the assumption that jeder ‘every(one)’ ‘‘is raised to a CP-adjoined position at LF’’ (p. 22).) Thus, (5), slightly adjusted from Beck’s work, must be the relevant simplified LF structure of (4), where IP forms a QUIB (induced by niemand ‘nobody’) and ti can not be bound by wo ‘where’ (because of the MQSC).
(6)

However, the syntactic assumptions Beck makes are not at all shared by everyone. In particular, within the Minimalist Program (Chomsky 1995), LF movement of the type first suggested by Huang (1982) is rejected: on the basis of well-motivated economy conditions, covert phrasal movement is replaced by feature movement. This is not the right place to indulge in a more elaborate discussion. As it turns out, one might cite works like Pesetsky 2000 and argue that covert phrasal movement is compatible with minimalism after all. And indeed Pesetsky endorses Beck-type intervention; he even couches a definition of it in a minimalist framework.
(7)

Again, however, this does not make the approach any more valid. As argued at length by Mathieu (2002), among others, there are empirical reasons to doubt the existence of covert phrasal movement in the relevant cases, that is, wh-questions.
One cannot help but agree with Mathieu’s appraisal that none of the explanations offered for this type of intervention (neither Beck’s nor Pesetsky’s, for example 6) ‘‘follow from anything’’ and that they ‘‘only amount to a restatement of the facts’’ (p. 174). Maybe the reasoning be hind it, possibly more explicit in (7) than (3), can be semantically motivated or even fleshed out; but with regard to the syntax involved here, I see very little hope. If anything, it should fall under some version of locality restrictions of the Relativized Minimality type (Rizzi 1990)—indeed, one could envision a greater relevance for negative islands, mentioned only in passing by Beck; see Boeckx 2003 and references cited for recent attempts in this direction.
Another problem with explicitly (and ‘‘crucially’’) defining intervention as an LF condition concerns the Uniformity Condition (see also Mathieu 1999). With the rise of the Minimalist Program and the denial of the existence of levels or components of representation other than those needed for the interfaces (LF, PF), uniformity as understood in (8) is important in the coherence of the grammar.
(8)

Finally, I want to mention in passing a further problem with intervention as understood in Beck and Kim 1997 (which is the same as Beck 1996a), noted by Kim (2003): as Beck and Kim’s discussion of wh scrambling in Korean shows, scrambling must be semantically effective (otherwise, intervention could not be called upon). This stands in stark contrast to the received wisdom that scrambling is semantically vacuous and involves radical reconstruction (Saito 1989). Here the facts for Korean seem to be duplicated in Japanese, the language Saito examines (see also Lee and Tomioka 2000).
Beyond theoretical concerns, the analysis encounters some empirical problems as well, which will play a major role in formulating an alternative. For example, Beck (1996a, 17) addresses some predictions of QUIB/ MQSC; one is that because of the barrier postulated by these conditions, elements should not be able to occur in the restriction of a (negative) quantifier. Among her supportive data is (9).
(9)

What is puzzling here is that none of the imaginable positive counter parts, without a negative quantifier inducing a barrier (or any of the other quantifiers that work for the QUIB/MQSC; see below for more), is any good either (see (10)). Beck’s formulation of intervention might have something to say about the ill-formedness of (9), but it does not relate at all to (10).
(10)


This said, since more narrowly defined multiple wh-questions constitute the focus of this chapter, I will simply disregard this puzzle (and the potential mismatch between what intervention is supposed to be ruling out and how that ties in with grammatical structures).